Why Medicare Advantage Plans Are Often Considered a Bad Choice.

Navigating the realm of healthcare plans can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to Medicare Advantage Plans. These plans are often touted as an all-inclusive solution, combining the benefits of Original Medicare with additional perks like prescription drug coverage, dental, and vision care. But is everything as rosy as it seems? Why are Medicare Advantage Plans considered bad?

In the following discussion, we will examine the less illuminated aspects of Medicare Advantage Plans, explore their pros and cons, and provide you with valuable insights to make an informed decision about why Medicare Advantage Plans are bad. Strap in and prepare to embark on a comprehensive exploration of Medicare Advantage Plans.

Key Takeaways

  • A Medicare Advantage Plan may restrict provider networks, leading to limited healthcare provider options and potentially higher out-of-pocket expenses due to drug deductibles, copays, and the risk of benefit denial.

  • According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, only about 46% of the doctors that accept Medicare will accept a Medicare Advantage Plan. Even then, they may not accept your Medicare Advantage Plan.

  • The complexity of Medicare Advantage plans can cause overwhelming choices for beneficiaries. Because their benefits and cost change each calendar year, an annual review is critically important. A Medicare Advantage Plan can change its network, benefits, out of pocket costs and any other feature each year.

  • Aggressive marketing tactics often mislead potential enrollees about the cost and benefits of Medicare Advantage Plans, confusing them about premium obligations and the nature of the coverage provided.

The Dark Side of Medicare Advantage Plans

 Medicare Advantage Plans, while offering a cohesive solution to healthcare needs, come with their fair share of issues. They may seem appealing with their bundled services, but it’s important to peel back the layers and understand what you’re signing up for.

The cons of Medicare Advantage includes:

  • Restricted provider networks, which limit the options of healthcare providers and specialists available to beneficiaries.

  • Limited to local coverage except for urgent care or emergencies.

  • Supplementary charges like drug deductibles and copays for specialist visits, leading to elevated out-of-pocket expenses for the beneficiaries

  • The possibility of benefits being denied for certain types of health care considered medically unnecessary by the plan, which is particularly worrisome for individuals with major health issues.

  • With a Medicare Advantage Plan you have traded in your Original Medicare for a privatized replacement. Your Medicare coverage is controlled by the insurance company, not Medicare.

It’s imperative to grasp these limitations when deciding on your health insurance coverage. To delve deeper into these issues, let’s break them down into sub-sections: Limited Provider Networks, High Out-of-Pocket Expenses, and Prior Authorization Hurdles.

Limited Provider Networks

One of the cons of Medicare Advantage plan is limited provider networks, managed by private sector insurance companies, can pose significant challenges for beneficiaries. With some Advantage Plans you cannot seek out-of-network care. With others, out-of-network care can only be approved if the doctor is willing to accept your insurance. This means you might not have access to your preferred healthcare providers, which can undermine the quality of your care.

Furthermore, your network of medical providers can change at any time.

High Out-of-Pocket Expenses

High out-of-pocket expenses are another significant concern with a Medicare Advantage Plan. These plans may entail greater out-of-pocket costs in comparison to Original Medicare and Medigap plans, rendering them less favorable for individuals with substantial healthcare requirements.

For example, you may have a daily copay for an inpatient hospital stay that exceeds the Medicare Part A hospital insurance deductible.

Moreover, the out-of-pocket threshold for Medicare Advantage plans is $8,850 in 2024 and can increase each year. Individuals with significant healthcare requirements are generally advised to retain their Original Medicare and Medicare supplement insurance. Medicare supplement insurance builds on your Original Medicare benefits, vastly improving your health insurance coverage.

Prior Authorization Hurdles

Although it may appear as a small annoyance, prior authorization required with Medicare Advantage Plans can pose significant hurdles and hinder your medical care.

With a Medicare Advantage Plan, the private insurance companies will require your doctor to seek prior authorization from the company before providing you the treatment they advise you need. This mandated process for certain medical services can cause delays and refusals of coverage. Prior authorization abuse has been the topic of two Inspector General Reports and multiple Congressional hearings for the harm they cause.

Services that frequently require prior authorization in Medicare Advantage plans encompass costly equipment and services, including durable medical equipment, Part B drugs, and inpatient hospital stays. In addition, prior authorization may be necessary for certain preventive services under certain plans. This requirement varies depending on the insurance company.

Confusing Plan Options and Annual Changes

Another issue with Medicare Advantage Plans is the complexity and overwhelming number of plan options available to beneficiaries. Whether you’re looking at HMOs, PPOs, MSAs, or PFFS plans, the sheer volume of choices can be daunting. On average, a typical Medicare beneficiary has access to 44 Medicare Advantage plans in a given year.

Additionally, there’s the matter of annual plan changes. Each year, Medicare Advantage plans undergo updates and modifications, which can impact covered services, benefits, and premiums. This necessitates an annual review of plans, which can be a complex and time-consuming and stressful process.

To better understand these issues, let’s break them down into two sub-sections: Overwhelming Choices and Annual Plan Alterations.

Overwhelming Choices

Navigating through the vast array of Medicare Advantage plans can be a daunting task. There are close to 4,000 different Medicare Advantage Plans in the U.S. and every year some plans close down while new plans are introduced.

The multitude of plan options, intricate plan attributes, and the substantial volume of information that beneficiaries must take into account when making a decision can lead to choice overload.

Annual Plan Changes

Annual plan changes add another layer of complexity to Medicare Advantage Plans. Any feature of a Medicare Advantage plan can change each year, affecting coverage, benefits, and premiums. Failing to review Medicare Advantage plans annually can lead to:

  • Enrolling in coverages that do not meet the needs of beneficiaries

  • Encountering unforeseen expenses

  • Forced changes to your primary care or specialist doctors.

  • Overpaying for prescription drugs.

It’s crucial for beneficiaries to juxtapose all available Medicare Advantage plan options, including their current plan, while assessing the costs and health needs during the open enrollment period every year.

Aggressive Marketing Tactics and Misleading Information

Unfortunately, the difficulties with Medicare Advantage Plans extend beyond intricate plan choices and substantial out-of-pocket expenses. Aggressive marketing tactics and misleading information are another aspect that potential enrollees need to be wary of.

During the annual Medicare open enrollment period from October 15 through December 07, consumers are inundated with advertisements designed to make Medicare Advantage enrollees feel like they are missing out of free benefits that should be included with their health care insurance. They are made to feel like they are missing out on covered services. The objective of the advertisements is to make the Medicare beneficiary feel a need to change their health care plan, even if it is not in their best interest.

Moreover, there’s a prevalent misconception surrounding $0 premiums associated with Medicare Advantage plans. Although many Advantage plans offer \$0 or low premiums, participants are still required to pay their Original Medicare Part B premium, which is not always clearly conveyed.

Comparing Medicare Advantage to Other Options

While it’s vital to comprehend the potential drawbacks of a Medicare Advantage Plan, it’s just as necessary to contrast them with other available alternatives. This includes Original Medicare, Medigap, and prescription drug coverage options.

Medicare Advantage Plans offer a minimum level of service designed to be roughly equivalent to Original Medicare. A Medicare Advantage plan often includes additional benefits such as a bundled Part D prescription drug coverage plan.

With Traditional Medicare (aka Original Medicare), prescription drugs are covered under a stand-alone Medicare Part D plan. This is separate Medicare drug coverage that can be changed annually without interfering with your primary healthcare insurance.

Advantage plans are sold to the consumer by leading them to believe they offer the same benefits as Original Medicare, but at a lower cost. This is not true. In fact, Medicare Advantage Plans cost the government 10% more than Original Medicare Part A and Medicare Part B.

Instead of focusing on the differences in healthcare between Original Medicare and a Medicare Advantage Plan, agents steer the consumer toward Advantage plans by promoting what I refer to as shiny objects. These are the “extra” benefits that are not directly healthcare related, like gym memberships, dental care or vision hearing and dental.

The agent wants the consumer to believe the Medicare Advantage plan covers the same benefits as that of Original Medicare, but they do not. They cover benefits from the same categories.

Some agents even suggest a Medicare Advantage Plan competes with Original Medicare plus a supplement, but the quality and quantity of medical care and insurance with a supplement plan is much greater.

Medigap, or Medicare Supplement insurance covers the gaps in Original Medicare. The gaps include the deductible, copays and coinsurance that would be the Medicare beneficiary’s out of pocket expense. Medicare Advantage enrollees cannot add a supplement. They must pay the copays, deductibles and coinsurance designated annually by the Advantage Plan.

Original Medicare and a Medigap policy

With Original Medicare, the Medicare enrollee can see any doctor or go to any medical facility in the U.S. or U.S. territory as long as they accept Traditional Medicare. If your doctor accepts Medicare, they will accept any Medicare supplemental coverage from any insurance company.

Original Medicare’s covers everything that is medically necessary and they rely on your doctor to determine medically necessary services. You can have a primary care physician, but are not required to obtain permission to see a specialist.

Prescription Drug Coverage

Prescription drug coverage is an integral part of healthcare, especially for seniors who often require multiple medications. Medicare Advantage Plans bundle health coverage and prescription drug coverage into a single plan, whereas standalone Part D plans provide independent prescription drug coverage through Medicare-approved private plans offered by private insurance companies.

However, it’s important to know that Part D plans are only for prescriptions that you would normally pick up at a pharmacy or mail order. Both Medicare Part B and Medicare Part A also provide coverage for prescription drugs under specific circumstances.

Tailoring Your Medicare Coverage: Tips for Making the Right Choice

Most people who choose a Medicare Advantage Plan instead of Original Medicare do so because of their budget. They understand that the out of pocket maximum of an Advantage plan can be difficult to afford, but are more willing to take that risk than the certainty of monthly premiums associated with a Medicare supplement. The Medigap policy premium is simply not in their budget. The low monthly premiums of an Advantage plan are more important than what they may pay out of pocket for doctor visits or other medical bills.

In addition, having extra benefits like dental coverage are more inviting for those who could not afford dental care if they had to pay monthly premiums.

Those who choose to keep their Original Medicare and add a supplemental coverage appreciate that they can see any doctor that accepts Medicare in the U.S. They have national medical insurance coverage with the lowest out of pocket costs of any Medicare coverage option.

For these people a separate Medicare drug plan is a benefit because they can change Part D drug plans without changing their health care options.

Consulting a Medicare Advisor

Consulting a Medicare advisor can greatly assist in making a well-informed decision. They can assist in understanding the complex landscape of Medicare and help identify plans that provide necessary coverage at competitive rates.

Remember, selecting the right Medicare plan is a crucial decision that can impact your financial and health situation long-term. Professional guidance can help you avoid costly mistakes and ensure you get the most out of your medical insurance coverage.


Navigating through the complex landscape of Medicare Advantage Plans can be daunting. While these plans can offer an all-in-one solution with additional benefits like prescription drug coverage, dental, and vision care, they come with their own set of challenges. These include limited provider networks, high out-of-pocket expenses, prior authorization hurdles, and confusing options due to annual changes.

However, by understanding your healthcare needs, comparing various options, and seeking professional guidance, you can make an informed decision that suits your budget and your needs. Remember, your health is your wealth. Making the right choice in your healthcare coverage can not only save you money but can also ensure you receive the best care possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the biggest disadvantage of Medicare Advantage?

The biggest disadvantage of Medicare Advantage is the fact that you have traded in your Original Medicare and given a for profit insurance company control over medial decisions.

Why do people say not to get a Medicare Advantage Plan?

People say not to get a Medicare Advantage Plan because it may have coverage limits and may not cover out-of-network providers, leading to higher out-of-pocket costs. Therefore, it’s important to carefully consider the potential limitations when choosing a plan.

Why doctors do not like Medicare Advantage plans?

Doctors may not like Medicare Advantage plans due to the provider restrictions within the network, which can affect their ability to provide services to patients. This can lead to doctors being hesitant to participate in these plans.

What is prior authorization in Medicare Advantage Plans?

Prior authorization in Medicare Advantage Plans is a required process for specific medical services, and it can result in coverage delays and denials. Be mindful of this when seeking services.

How do Medicare Advantage Plans compare to Original Medicare and Medigap?

Medicare Advantage Plans typically have higher out-of-pocket costs and a more restricted provider network compared to Original Medicare and Medigap. Consider these factors when making your decision.


Matthew Claassen, CMT and CEO of Medigap Seminars Insurance Agency. Medigap Seminars is an award winning premier national Medicare Insurance Brokerage, ranked among the top in the U.S.A. Matthew is considered a leading national expert on Medicare and Social Security. Mr. Claassen is a distinguished member of the Forbes Business council, an invitation only organization of business leaders and entrepreneurs. He and his team have received awards from many of the countries largest insurance companies including Mutual of Omaha, Aetna, Humana, Cigna, United American, United Healthcare and others. His videos have become the most popular Medicare educational videos on YouTube with millions of views. As a financial analyst Matthew lead a team of researchers to win the 2009 Best Equity Research & Strategy Award from The Technical analysis magazine.


Talk to an Expert

Contact Us

MM slash DD slash YYYY
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Join our Free 6-Day Medicare Mini Course

We’ll send you 6 email lessons with short videos that explain all the basics you need to know about Medicare. Plus BONUS New-to Medicare Checklist and Cost Worksheet to help you estimate your costs for Medicare.